Reviews for Scandals
Booklist Reviews 2011 September #1
The Olympic creed may state that the most important thing is not to win but to have performed well, but as this fascinating entry in The Olympics series shows, some have taken this as a suggestion that they can ignore, rather than an oath. (Playing fast and loose with the goal of sportsmanship goes back to ancient Greece.) The book is divided into chapters that cover such topics as bribes, doping, and political problems. Along with famous events, such as the tragedy at the Munich Olympics, in which Israeli athletes were murdered, and the Marion Jones running scandal, in which she was stripped of her medals, there are other shocking and surprising moments. For instance, an East German woman was given so many drugs (without her knowledge) that she later had to have a sex-change operation. The final chapter, detailing future problems athletes and officials may encounter, is particularly interesting. This slim volume, full of historical and contemporary photos, gives readers a lot to think about. A glossary and time line are appended. Copyright 2011 Booklist Reviews.
Horn Book Guide Reviews 2012 Spring
Cluttered page design (including many photographs) and poor organization mar these volumes about the Olympics; the various sidebars, including "Amazing Olympics" and "Facts and Stats," are not well differentiated from the main texts' content. More detailed timelines would have been helpful, as would lists for comparison. All four books could easily be in one volume. Websites. Glos., ind. [Review covers these Olympics titles: Events, History, Records, and Scandals.]
School Library Journal Reviews 2011 November
Gr 4-7--These books emphasize summer sports, although on occasion winter events are inserted within the appropriate context. While Butterfield uses a narrative approach to topics, each volume has plenty of "Olympic Facts and Stats," sidebars, and colorful photographs to bring variety to the pages. There is some overlap of information among the titles. The author adds elements of humor by relaying certain facts, such as that women were not allowed to compete in track events until 1928 because running was considered unladylike and dangerous. These books could be used to talk about ethics or to zero in on topics for reports, yet there is no insight here that is not available elsewhere. [Page 58]. (c) Copyright 2011. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.