Reviews for Circulatory Story
Booklist Reviews 2010 January #1
Showing why "it's great to circulate," the author and illustrator of The Quest to Digest (2006) take young readers on an equally engaging ride through the heart, lungs, arteries, veins, capillaries, and back again. In the big, labeled cartoon illustrations a small, green Shmoo-like creature rides a red blood cell down a river of plasma ("YEE HAW!"), "passes gas" to a body cell in exchange for a bag of CO2, sits back to watch as white blood cells and platelets race to a skinned knee, then threateningly wards off a cheeseburger and other fatty, arterial plaque-causing foods. Corcoran's breezy commentary lays out the whole 60,000-mile system in easy-to-understand terms, giving readers a chance to add words like erythrocyte, leukocyte, and sino-atrial node to their personal lexicons and closing with well-chosen books and Web sites to spur further investigation. An irresistible invitation to go with the flow. Copyright 2010 Booklist Reviews.
Horn Book Guide Reviews 2010 Fall
A cartoonish character rides a red blood cell throughout the human circulatory system, examining its major components and their functions. Colorful cartoon illustrations, zany asides, and liberal use of exclamation points fail to lighten the heavy scientific content. Reading list, websites. Bib., glos. Copyright 2010 Horn Book Guide Reviews.
Library Media Connection Reviews 2010 October
Best known for his graphic novel and an artistic styling that might remind readers of early Matt Groening, illustrator Jef Czekaj has teamed up once again with Mary K. Corcoran. Czekaj gets top billing here because his work is what distinguishes this book from others on the same topic. A little green imp, one eye disproportionately large, in typical Czekaj style, takes a wild ride through the circulatory system using blood cells as an inner tube down the rapids. His host is a bespectacled red-headed girl. Along the way, readers learn about the heart and its valves, the role of veins and arteries and capillaries in transporting blood, and the lungs? importance in keeping blood oxygen rich and disposing of carbon dioxide. Our immune system, pus as an indicator of infection, and the importance of clotting are all given a nod as well. Corcoran?s text is as accessible as it is informative. Czekaj?s art, often presented in near-fluorescent colors, can be a bit distracting and too busy. Bibliography. Glossary. Websites. Recommended. Rich Parker, Media Specialist, Laytonsville (Maryland) Elementary School ¬ 2010 Linworth Publishing, Inc.
School Library Journal Reviews 2010 April
Gr 2-4--Corcoran attempts to provide a simple, yet humorous explanation of the circulatory system. Her treatment is cursory and requires that readers imagine themselves as a little green imp traveling onboard a red blood cell floating along in a girl's plasma. The narrative often comes across as confusing and unclear. Sections such as "The Arching Aorta" use words in the illustrations that are not explained in the text or in the extensive glossary ("externa," "media," "intima"). The author uses asides, such as "Did you get a charge out of that?" and "Pee-yew! Your red blood cell just passed gas," that detract from understanding the many complicated words that are presented superficially in the text. On the other hand, the digitally colored line illustrations are interestingly detailed and offer a light touch. The font is large and attractively arranged on colorful backgrounds. This book would best be used as a supplement to such titles as Paul Showers's Hear Your Heart (HarperCollins, 2001).--Blair Christolon, Prince William Public Library System, Manassas, VA [Page 144]. Copyright 2008 Reed Business Information.