Reviews for Even an Octopus Needs a Home


Booklist Reviews 2011 December #2
Similar in title, format, and concept to Kelly's Even an Ostrich Needs a Nest (2009), her new book goes beyond birds to introduce structures that house creatures throughout the animal kingdom. From monk parakeet "apartment buildings" to floating birds' nests to coral reefs "like underground cities," Kelly looks at domiciles created or used by animals and sometimes likens them to people's houses. Though assertions such as "Chimpanzees love a view" may be anthropomorphic, parents and teachers looking for picture books showing animal homes will appreciate the book's relatively simple text and attractive watercolor illustrations as well as the variety of habitations shown. Copyright 2011 Booklist Reviews.

----------------------
Horn Book Guide Reviews 2012 Spring
From temporary leafy nests for chimpanzees to giant long-lasting reefs for corals; from lofty termite towers to deep badger burrows, all animals need some kind of a home. Appealing watercolor, gouache, and pen-and-ink illustrations, including some cross-sections of the dwellings, clearly show the animals and their shelters. The text, while informative, is set in distractingly wavy paragraph blocks.

----------------------
Kirkus Reviews 2011 August #1

Building on her successful Even an Ostrich Needs a Nest (2009), Kelly expands the concept to describe how others in the animal world make and find safe places for rest, safety and rearing their young.

From chimpanzees building temporary sleeping platforms each night to male Siamese fighting fish hiding eggs in a mass of bubbles, the author-illustrator offers a wide variety of examples. These are loosely organized by type: A tree house, tower, lodge, cave, burrow or bubble can serve as a temporary or permanent home. It might even be floating or mobile. Illustrations done in watercolor, gouache, pen and ink surround an informal narrative set in wavy lines on each page. There are a few missteps: The bee's comb has both honey and larvae, although brood combs are usually separate from honey combs. Text about bats sleeping in caves is illustrated with flying fox bats hanging from trees. Careful reading reveals that the nests, cells, tunnels and dens the author describes are used for nightly beds, places for hatching eggs and raising families or protective hideaways, but not always all three. The conclusion, calling these places where animals "live," supports a common misunderstanding of animal behavior.

Animals do not have "homes" as humans do. For the intended audience that cozy connection is an unfortunate oversimplification in an otherwise appealing title. (Informational picture book. 5-9)

Copyright Kirkus 2011 Kirkus/BPI Communications.All rights reserved.

----------------------
Library Media Connection Reviews 2012 March/April
In style and format similar to her Even an Ostrich Needs a Nest: Where Birds Begin (Holiday House, 2009), Kelly examines how and where 13 different animals make their homes. It moves from a chimpanzee's 80 foot high sleeping platform in the tree tops, to weaver birds' purse-like nests, to beaver dams, and so on. The author's illustrations are accurate, colorful, fascinating, and compliment the text well. Science minded children will love this! Even children who aren't nonfiction fans may change their minds after experiencing all these animal homes. Even primary grade students will enjoy it as a read-aloud. Sherry Hoy, Library Media Specialist, Tuscarora JHS and Juniata HS, Mifflintown, Pennsylvania. RECOMMENDED Copyright 2012 Linworth Publishing, Inc.

----------------------
School Library Journal Reviews 2011 October

K-Gr 3--Using illustrations done in watercolor, gouache, and pen and ink, Kelly introduces various animal homes. She divides the residences into categories: tree houses, towers, lodges, caves, burrows, floating and mobile homes, and bubbles. Some are familiar; others are more unusual, like the monk parakeet's treetop apartment buildings. The artist's palette skillfully broadens to accommodate each habitat, from the Great Barrier Reef to the brown bear's winter den. The well-labeled paintings are realistic and range from close-ups to a span of ocean floor. The baby bat peeping out from its mother's wing embrace is charming. The informational bits are ideal in length; they're great for fast-fact lovers but will tease out further study in many cases. The important message of environmental stewardship--"all animals…need homes for the same reason: to have a safe and snug place to live and raise a family"--should resonate with children.--Gay Lynn Van Vleck, Henrico County Library, Glen Allen, VA

[Page 127]. (c) Copyright 2011. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

----------------------