Reviews for Secretary : A Journey With Hillary Clinton from Beirut to the Heart of American Power
Booklist Reviews 2013 February #2
*Starred Review* Ghattas, half Dutch and half Lebanese, grew up in Beirut witnessing firsthand the consequences of foreign policy decisions made in Washington. She came to the U.S. in 2008 as a BBC reporter covering the State Department and got to see the other side of American foreign decision making. She brings those unique perspectives to this engaging look at U.S. diplomacy under Hillary Clinton, former First Lady and presidential candidate. Drawing on interviews with Clinton, her staff, and major figures in the U.S. and around the world, Ghattas presents a close-up look at the touchiest of diplomatic issues in the first Obama administration, from the Arab Spring uprisings to WikiLeaks. She offers a glimpse of the personal side of Clinton at a surprise town-hall meeting in Baghdad, talking with the Saudi king in his personal and well-appointed bus, cajoling and charming but remaining firm on U.S. positions. Ghattas also presents a rich portrait of the different perspectives on U.S. power and influence around the world as well as her own personal experiences and ambivalence about the U.S. as she learns the realities of U.S. power: there is no magic wand, and solutions aren't obvious or automatic. Copyright 2012 Booklist Reviews.
Choice Reviews 2014 February
Ghattas, a Lebanese-born BBC correspondent, traveled with Secretary of State Hillary Clinton for four years and for much of Hillary's record-breaking one million miles. Her portrait of Clinton as individual, diplomat, personality, and, in the author's words, "the face--and the heart--of American power" is a unique kind of study. It is part historical narrative, personal memoir, insider account of day-to-day operations and travel logistics, gossip, commentary on the processes and conduct of American policy, critique, and praise for Hillary that, at points, approaches hagiography. The glimpses into world leaders, recent crisis management, and the dynamics among US policy makers are fascinating. Into this story Ghattas weaves her personal saga of her childhood during the Lebanese Civil War in the 1970s and how it affected her perspectives on the later Syrian Civil War. Critics will consider the volume an Obama/Clinton apologia, and such early journalist accounts seldom stand the test of time against later in-depth scholarship. But the book is a good first-blush introduction to the role of Hillary Clinton in the diplomacy of the first Obama administration. Whatever readers' politics, the volume is an engaging and enjoyable read. Summing Up: Recommended. General readers through research faculty. General Readers; Lower-division Undergraduates; Upper-division Undergraduates; Graduate Students; Researchers/Faculty. J. P. Dunn Converse College Copyright 2014 American Library Association.
Kirkus Reviews 2012 December #2
An intimate, admiring look at the four-year global travails of the secretary of state from a member of her traveling press corps. A Beirut-born BBC journalist assigned to the U.S. State Department in 2008, Ghattas has closely observed Clinton in her busy, high-profile position as secretary over the last four years. Here, she records her key role in the reshaping of American foreign policy. Ghattas' work is invaluable in revealing the effort behind the headlines, from Clinton's choice of Japan for her maiden voyage to sparring with the Israelis, Pakistanis and Chinese, plugging holes from WikiLeaks revelations and riding the eruptions of Arab uprisings. Yet here also is a rare glimpse of the woman behind the glamorous name and powerful credentials: Flanked by her devoted young assistants, Clinton often ventured to the back of the plane, sans makeup and wearing her glasses, to share a drink and chat off the record with the cadre of reporters who regularly traveled with her around the world. Unlike her buttoned-up predecessor, Condoleezza Rice, Clinton seemed to relax amid her staggering travels and meetings, usually running late ("on Hillary time") but giving everyone her full attention, speaking to rapt audiences and letting the officers who held her agenda sweat it out. Wielding her "soft agenda" of women's rights, moving to repair much of the damage imposed by the Bush administration, such as the invasion of Iraq, and appeasing foes who gloated on America's "imperial overstretch," Clinton was quietly but firmly reaffirming U.S. leadership. Along the way, Ghattas, as a Lebanese woman who keenly felt the American betrayal of her country during the long civil war of 1975 to 1990, comes to a sense of forgiveness and understanding of American might. A personal look at the Secretary's diplomacy via a flexible, pragmatic approach rather than ideology. Copyright Kirkus 2012 Kirkus/BPI Communications.All rights reserved.
Library Journal Reviews 2013 March #1
The Obama administration has made much of its secretary of state's indefatigable travel; Ghattas, a correspondent for the BBC at the U.S. State Department, provides an accessible and detailed account of this aspect of Clinton's work, covering all major areas of the world through early 2012. Ghattas engagingly describes the logistical and personal demands on Clinton, but gives much less attention to the larger political context of Clinton's work. Certain episodes, such as the difficulty of coordinating Washington's leadership on Iranian sanctions and the 2010 "WikiLeaks" scandal, are highly informative, showing, in the latter case, Clinton's devotion to undoing the damage from the leaked documents. Ghettas brings her Lebanese origins to bear in her personal quest to determine American involvement in Syria's 1990 invasion of her country, an interest satisfied through the same energy she brings to accompanying her subject to many countries. VERDICT This is not a serious biography or an inside story about the Obama administration, but it will find an audience among the many readers who find Hillary Clinton a fascinating subject.--Zachary Irwin, Behrend Coll., Penn State Univ., Erie [Page 82]. (c) Copyright 2013. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Publishers Weekly Reviews 2012 December #4
Secretary of State Hillary Clinton becomes the face of a superpower in this captivating profile. Ghattas, State Department correspondent for the BBC, jetted around the globe with Clinton as she refereed Israeli-Palestinian quarrels, wrangled with Chinese officialdom, smoothed ruffled diplomatic feathers after Wikileaks publicized catty American cables, and strategized over the Arab Spring upheavals. In Ghattas's vivid portrait, Clinton emerges as a charismatic, tireless woman, magnetic during her trademark town hall meetings with ordinary citizens (cries of "We love you, Hillary" trail her everywhere), candid and forthright in private conversation, but always agonizing over anodyne public statements that will be obsessively parsed for policy shifts. But as the author floats along in Clinton's exciting, exhausting bubble of pre-eminence, she also examines America's ongoing centrality in world affairs: while they resent American power, in every country people she encounters expect the United States to magically settle their crises and conflicts. Attuned to that mindset since her childhood in war-torn Lebanon, Ghattas receives in her travels with Clinton an eye-opening education in the complexity and limitations of U.S. foreign policy making. Her perceptive reportage on Clinton's personal leadership grounds a shrewd analysis of America's role as the still-indispensable nation. 8-page b&w photo insert. Agent: Dorian Karchmar, William Morris Endeavor. (Mar. 5) [Page ]. Copyright 2012 PWxyz LLC