Reviews for Three Swingin' Pigs
Horn Book Guide Reviews 2007 Fall
Satch, Mo, and Ella (whose uncles are the Three Pigs) compose the Three Swingin' Pigs jazz trio. Big Bad Wolfie pursues them but instead discovers a love of music and joins the band. In a text accompanied by quirky, angular acrylic illustrations, the improvisational rhythm is appropriate to the jazzy theme but makes the story hard to follow, and the hepcat wordplay is overdone. Copyright 2007 Horn Book Guide Reviews.
Kirkus Reviews 2007 April #2
Though as big and baaaaaad as ever--"I'm a classic fairy-tale villain," he proudly proclaims--the wolf has no better luck chowing down on jazz-combo piggies Satch, Mo and Ella than he did with their uncles in that other tale. Rendered in the high-energy art as a duded-up, super-skinny figure with a long ski nose and breath so stunningly bad that it comes out in a noxious green cloud, the determined wolf scores a ticket to the pigs' latest gig, elbows his way to the front of the packed Smokehouse--and then gets invited up on stage by scat-singing Ella to show his chops (so to speak). A crowd-pleasing howl and some huffing and puffing on the sax later, he's given up his predatory purpose to become the band's newest member. Montijo's red-hot pictures and Rubin's skit-scat-skedoodle words make this take-off a hand-clapping, foot-stomping romp. (Picture book. 6-8) Copyright Kirkus 2007 Kirkus/BPI Communications. All rights reserved.
Library Media Connection - November/December 2007
What happened after the Big Bad Wolf left the brick home of the third little pig? Author Vicky Rubin describes what happens when the nephews and niece of the original three pigs meet the wolf. However, this time . . . the ending is much, much different. In this story, music is how the pigs communicate, with text in jazzy scat, but will their music make the wolf forget about his ham dinner? Rhode Montijo's illustrations capture the jazz era perfectly. Children will love the pictures, and those who know the story of "The Three Little Pigs" will truly become engaged in what happens next. Recommended. Brenda Rogers, 4th and 5th Grade Teacher, Children's Academy, Kent, Washington © 2007 Linworth Publishing, Inc.
Publishers Weekly Reviews 2007 May #4
Attempting to reverse the fortune of the three not-so-lucky little pigs of the classic fairytale, Rubin (Ralphie and the Swamp Baby ) offers up an easygoing porcine trio, cast as cool jazz musicians with an enthusiastic following. The text is as smooth as the main characters, the token wolf dubbed the "baddest cat" and the pigs referred to as Satch, Mo and Ella (a nod to the great Armstrong and Fitzgerald). Unlike the wolf in the original tale, this one must go to great lengths to get hold of these starlets--his initial plan to devour them onstage is foiled when he can't get a ticket to their show. Montijo's (Cloud Boy ) lively neon acrylics keep pace with action; some of the best feature fairytale cameos, as the wolf is shown offending Little Red Riding Hood with his "stinky breath" (a running gag throughout) or running off with a half-eaten Gingerbread Man. "What did you expect?" the wolf quips, "I'm a classic fairy-tale villain." Once the wolf finally gets his intended victims within reach, the self-assured piggies do the unthinkable by inviting him onstage--killing him with kindness, instead of a bubbling cauldron. The story ends on an upbeat note, as the newly formed quartet belts out a happy tune. Kids should get a kick out of this hip riff on an old standard. Ages 5-9. (May) [Page 62]. Copyright 2007 Reed Business Information.
School Library Journal Reviews 2007 June
Gr 1-4-- Toe-tapping, claw-snapping, and bebopping replace the usual huffing and puffing in this jazzed-up version of the traditional folktale. Porcine siblings Ella, Satch, and Mo have formed a trio that is all the rage with their animal audiences. Their successful musical future is in jeopardy, however, when Wolfie, a self-described "classic fairy-tale villain," decides to exact retribution for his failure to capture their uncles in earlier days. Will the three swingin' pigs win over Wolfie with their sweet music? Fortunately for them, he's a bit of a ham and loves performing. Full of porker-inspired puns and clever repartee, this fast-paced tale has definite appeal. The colorful, cartoonlike acrylic illustrations are a perfect match for the zany, slightly over-the-top story line. Whether used as part of a unit on fractured fairy tales or read independently just for fun, this version will have its audience howling.--Maura Bresnahan, High Plain Elementary School, Andover, MA [Page 122]. Copyright 2007 Reed Business Information.