Reviews for Hound Dog True

Booklist Reviews 2011 September #1
Painfully shy, Mattie quails at starting a new school next week, though it might be better with Uncle Potluck as school custodian. He lets Mattie help, and she hopes to prove herself indispensable and become a Custodial Apprentice. She meticulously writes down all she learns from Uncle Potluck in a notebook labeled "Custodial Wisdom." But will Uncle Potluck's tips and "hound dog true" stories really help her navigate the terrors of friendship? The story brims with personality and fully realized characters, especially Uncle Potluck, whose expansive nature and vocabulary are quirky but believable. Written in third person from Mattie's perspective, sentence fragments sprinkled throughout create a jaunty cadence, and gentle humor bubbles through Mattie's observations, as when she notes that one teacher wears flip-flops. "Mattie is glad she will not be in his class. Seems wrong to know your teacher has hair on his toes." Internal drama, compelling characters, and Mattie's strong voice propel the story of learning to do "a small brave thing." Copyright 2011 Booklist Reviews.

BookPage Reviews 2011 September
A writer's first brave steps

In just one week, fifth grader Mattie Breen, custodial apprentice and secret storyteller, will face the moment she always dreads: introducing herself in front of her classmates in yet another new school.

This time, as she helps her Uncle Potluck, director of custodial arts at Mitchell P. Anderson Elementary School, prepare for the opening of school, Mattie stands in the empty classroom and wonders what it will be like. Is it possible that, for once, she can find words to say that will magically bring her friends? Can she say something that will make her more than “that shy girl?”

Mattie is the engaging young heroine of Linda Urban’s lyrical new novel for young readers, Hound Dog True. Urban brings Mattie’s emotions to life so perceptively it’s natural to wonder if the author herself was shy as a child, or if, like Mattie, she had the experience of being teased about her writing. 

“It is risky to be earnest. It is risky to show that you care. Irony is like wearing bubble wrap.”

“When I was a kid, I wrote all the time—joyfully and fearlessly,” Urban remembers during a call to her home in Vermont. “Then in seventh grade, we were given an assignment to write about Christmas Eve. I wrote a piece that was filled with memory and detail—I really put my heart into it. We were asked to read our pieces aloud and I did, and a boy in my class said that one of the words I used was weird. And that I was weird for having used it.”

The incident had an effect on the direction Urban took. She stopped writing fiction and went on to study advertising and journalism in college. Eventually she became a bookseller at an independent bookstore in Pasadena, California, before moving to Vermont with her family seven years ago. 

But as for writing fiction herself? 

“Too risky. Too scary,” the author says. 

In fact, Urban didn’t begin writing fiction again until age 37, when she started reading picture books to her baby daughter. She began getting up early (a writing habit she continues now as the mother of a nine- and seven-year-old), and didn’t even admit to her husband for months that she was trying her hand at writing children’s literature.

Urban’s first novel for children, A Crooked Kind of Perfect, published in 2007, tells the story of a girl who dreams of getting a baby grand piano but gets an organ instead. The book received many accolades, including being named a selection of the Junior Library Guild. In 2009 Urban published a picture book, Mouse Was Mad, illustrated by Henry Cole. This amusing story for preschoolers about an angry mouse who tries to handle his emotions was also praised by reviewers.

Now, with three books to her credit and another novel in the works, Urban is an advocate for young writers like Mattie. “My own memories of writing that Christmas piece in seventh grade and the reaction I got from my classmates had a little to do with the emotional core of Hound Dog True and Mattie’s fear about sharing her writing,” she says. 

“I do a lot of school visits and hear from young writers who are afraid to tell people they write. It’s common, that fear. Not just of sharing writing, but of risking. It is risky to show how much you care about the things you do or try. I think that is why we live in such an ironic age. It is risky to be earnest. It is risky to show that you care. Irony is like wearing bubble wrap.”

In Hound Dog True, Mattie learns a lot about what it means to take risks—not just in showing her writing to others, but in taking the first small steps toward friendship with another girl, Quincy Sweet, who, like Mattie, must find her own way amid the expectations of others. Having a real, intimate friend—a friend you can be honest with—is scary for Mattie, but as her new principal tells her, “You can’t have brave without scared.”

Urban is an acute observer of these small steps toward bravery, independence and friendship. An inveterate reader herself (her entire household dedicates Tuesday evenings to “Read at the Table Night,” where kids and parents bring a book to a finger-food dinner), Urban loves “heart and honesty and humor. I love brilliant turns of phrase that never threaten to hijack the story. I love people who understand the underside of kids, but maintain an outlook that is hopeful and generous.

“I tend to write about moments and choices that seem small to outsiders but are huge to the people experiencing them,” Urban continues. “In this book, I hoped to show how hard those small, brave, risky steps can be—and also how rewarding.”

And so, when Mattie Breen does find herself standing in front of her new fifth grade classmates on the first day of school, readers will be pulling for her to speak up and declare who she is—a girl who writes stories.


Copyright 2011 BookPage Reviews.

Horn Book Guide Reviews 2012 Spring
Shy Mattie and her mama come to live with Uncle Potluck, the custodian of the school where, in one week, Mattie will enter fifth grade. Mattie helps Uncle Potluck get the school ready and takes a sense of security from keeping her Custodial Wisdom notebook; in doing so, she begins to find her voice. Her slow and painful self-examination is honest and true. Copyright 2012 Horn Book Guide Reviews.

Horn Book Magazine Reviews 2011 #5
As Mattie's peripatetic mother always says, "When the going gets tough, the tough get going." And "going" is what the two of them are always doing, moving from job to job, house to house, and school to school. But Mattie's not as tough as Mama; she's shy, afraid to open up to others, and keeps it to herself when a classmate hu iliates her after reading a story Mattie wrote that "came from someplace inside of her." Her internal voice makes Mattie practice just the right thing to say in front of others, but it refuses to appear on cue, and she winds up mute or twisting her words. As the book opens, Mattie and Mama have come to live with Uncle Potluck, the custodian of the school where, in one week, Mattie will enter the fifth grade. Mattie develops a sense of responsibility helping Uncle Potluck get the school ready and finds a sense of security in keeping her Custodial Wisdom notebook, writing down the tricks of the trade; finally, Mattie has the courage to write another story as she begins to find her voice. Although there's a strong support system surrounding Mattie, she alone can discover what matters in life. Her slow and painful self-examination is honest; her revelations are "hound dog true." betty carter Copyright 2011 Horn Book Magazine Reviews.

Kirkus Reviews 2011 August #2

With a little help from a caring adult, a child crippled by shyness begins to bloom.

Soon-to-be fifth grader Mattie is painfully shy, making the frequent moves her mother has initiated especially difficult. In the last days of summer, after she and her mother move in with her Uncle Potluck, the elementary-school custodian, he quickly recognizes both her talent and her difficulties and begins bringing her to work with him, where she records everything he does in her journal (since she's a writer). She hopes that if she learns enough custodial skills, she can become his junior apprentice during lunch and recess and so avoid the most challenging times of the school day. Meanwhile, she is studiously steering clear of Quincy, a slightly older girl visiting next door; in trying to avoid the social minefield of friendship, she fails to recognize that Quincy is a kindred spirit. As amiable Potluck gently guides her, and her jittery but loving mother comes to better understand her, Mattie believably begins to turn from her inwardly focused timidity to an eye-opening awareness of the complexity of others' emotional landscapes. Combining Mattie's poignant writing and interior monologue, exquisite character development and a slow, deliberate pace, Urban spins a story that rings true.

This outstanding, emotionally resonant effort will appeal to middle-grade readers. (Fiction. 8-12)

Copyright Kirkus 2011 Kirkus/BPI Communications.All rights reserved.

Publishers Weekly Reviews 2011 July #4

Urban (A Crooked Kind of Perfect) traces a highly self-conscious child's cautious emergence from her shell in this tender novel about new beginnings and "small brave" acts. Fifth grader Mattie Breen doesn't share her mother's eagerness to pick up stakes whenever "the going gets tough." Mattie hates starting over at unfamiliar schools, but when her mother announces they will be living with Uncle Potluck, Mattie feels hopeful, for once. Uncle Potluck tells funny, larger-than-life stories--the kind of stories Mattie likes to write, but is embarrassed to share with others. Mattie hopes that Uncle Potluck will make her his "custodial apprentice" at the school where he works (and which she'll attend) and that this time she'll finally find a "true, tell-your-secrets-to" friend. Urban's understated, borderline naïf narrative gives voice to Mattie's many uncertainties ("Always Mattie has been shy. Always school had made her feel skittish and small") while expressing the quiet yet significant moments in her day-to-day life. Mattie's growing trust of others and her attempts to be "bold and friendly" lead to gratifying rewards for Mattie and poignant moments for readers. Ages 9-12. (Sept.)

[Page ]. Copyright 2010 PWxyz LLC

School Library Journal Reviews 2011 October

Gr 4-6--Mattie Breen is a self-conscious and sensitive child about to begin fifth grade in her fifth school. This time, she and her mother are back in her mother's girlhood home with Uncle Potluck, the "Director of Custodial Arts" at the school Mattie is slated to attend. She dreads the prospect of recesses and lunch times--any times where she might find herself in unpredictable social situations--so she devises a plan to become her uncle's invaluable assistant. As he prepares the school during the last week of summer, Mattie accompanies him and records "Custodial Wisdom" in a silver notebook. She hopes to impress him so that he will want her help during the school day. Uncle Potluck is an intelligent, positive character, and he adds an extra heap of credibility to his many stories by referring to them as "hound dog true." He is a kind and sensitive example for his reclusive niece--a storyteller, like her. Quinn, who is visiting next door, and is as much an artist as Mattie is a writer, also makes a start in bringing the timid girl out of her shell. The most action readers will find in this story is Uncle Potluck tripping over a vacuum cleaner cord, but the characters are well limned, and Mattie's perceptions and observations add a tender dimension. There are many books that offer adventure and twists and unusual story lines. Most of them do not offer young readers such fine writing and real characters. That is hook enough.--Corrina Austin, Locke's Public School, St. Thomas, Ontario, Canada

[Page 150]. (c) Copyright 2011. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.