Reviews for January's Sparrow
Booklist Reviews 2009 October #2
Told from the viewpoint of Sadie Crosswhite, a young child who was born into slavery, this dramatic picture book is based on true events that took place in Marshall, Michigan, near where Polacco lives today. The narrative begins with shocking brutality on a Kentucky plantation: Sadie and her family watch while her foster brother, January, is whipped and kicked to death for trying to escape to freedom. With the threat of being auctioned off, the family members run away that night, bound for Canada, and the unframed pictures show their journey on the Underground Railroad, pursued by the slave catchers with savage dogs, until they find shelter in Marshall. Will they be safe there? Are there spies? Sadie goes to school and makes friends, but then the slave catchers come, and so does a surprising visitor. The characters' melodramatic expressions in the colored-pencil-and-marker artwork sometimes overstate and simplify the complex emotions in the words. Still, Sadie's first-person narrative, in modified dialect, captures the terror, excitement, and hope of the powerful history. Copyright 2009 Booklist Reviews.
Horn Book Magazine Reviews 2009 #6
After an escaped slave has been found and returned to a Kentucky plantation to be whipped to death, young Sadie Crosswhite and her family decide they must escape themselves, making for the Ohio River, where they are taken across to Indiana by a "rowin' girl." The family eventually reaches a protective community in Michigan, where they live safely until found by their erstwhile owner; he demands their return, and the law is on his side. Like Polacco's Civil War story Pink and Say (rev. 11/94), this long picture book is based on a true historical incident, one that illuminates the necessity and strategies of the Underground Railroad. Polacco makes the history dramatic and compelling, writing with a minimum of dialect and sentimentality (the last being the bane of Pink and Say). Save for some cartooning in the faces, the pictures for January's Sparrow reveal Polacco at her best: fluid and confident drawing, and an impressive command of the use of the page. Generally filling two-thirds of each double-page spread (occasionally, effectively, spilling across the whole expanse), the pencil and marker illustrations convey the drama through the positions of bodies, leaning in or away, running or at peace. Mood and suspense are created by perspective: right up close as the waves of the dangerous Ohio threaten their boat, and on the next spread pulling back to reveal the calm moon- and starlit shore of the welcoming Indiana riverbank. The story and images alike are sometimes brutal (such as a picture of the scarred back of a whipped man) but undeniably vivid. Copyright 2009 Horn Book Magazine Reviews.
Kirkus Reviews 2009 September #1
A voice in the prologue, in the dialect cadences of the slave narratives, introduces the stark opening image of a black man, roped and bloodied, dragged by two white men on horseback--the paddy rollers. Eight-year-old Sadie Crosswhite is forced to watch with her parents and siblings as their beloved friend, January Drumm, is whipped and carried off for burial, the price for trying to run away. Sadie and her family run away that night, stopping in Marshall, Mich., with its free black community. They tell no one that they are runaways, as harboring them is against the law. The slave catchers track the Crosswhites down some four years later, in 1847, and in a blazing scene the townspeople of Marshall, black and white, defy them, even as January himself appears, baring his horribly scarred back. Polacco's passionately realized images use every tool in the artist's arsenal: pictures structured like Expressionist etchings or Mannerist saints; echoes of Delacroix and Ryder, Rembrandt and Goya. Rooted in history (a comprehensive bibliography is promised online), this is a masterly narrative that horrifies, moves and informs. (Illustrated fiction. 9-14) Copyright Kirkus 2009 Kirkus/BPI Communications.All rights reserved.
Library Media Connection Reviews 2010 January/February
Because Patricia Polacco lives near Marshall, Michigan, and because of her interest in civil rights, she researched the story of the Crosswhite family during the days of slavery. January, whom the Crosswhites had taken in when he was a young boy, is beaten because he ran away, and they think he is dead. The Crosswhites run away from their master when they hear that their boys are going to be sold. This is the story of their journey and fear of getting caught. After they reach Michigan, a free state, they establish themselves in Marshall. One day a wooden sparrow that January had carved shows up with a note saying ?I found you.? Was he alive, or had the slave catchers found them? They load up and go to Canada. The Crosswhites later return to Michigan after Lincoln frees the slaves. Patricia Polacco?s pictures and story bring the Crosswhite account to life. I loved reading January?s Sparrow, but it was hard looking at the pictures, knowing that the beatings were a reality. It would be a good book to add to your collection for author study and discussion. Recommended. Sue N. Howard, Library Media Specialist, Georgia Avenue Elementary, Memphis, Tennessee ¬ 2010 Linworth Publishing, Inc.
Publishers Weekly Reviews 2009 September #4
Based on actual events, Polacco's (In Our Mothers' House) story is at once horrifying and heartening. It centers on the Crosswhite family, slaves who flee their Kentucky plantation after witnessing the merciless whipping of January, a slave caught while attempting escape. Led to believe that January died from his wounds, Sadie Crosswhite is heartbroken when she inadvertently leaves behind the wooden sparrow he carved for her. Writing in credible dialect, Polacco conveys the family's fear and fortitude as they follow the North Star, "trackin' through cornfields, climbin' up bluffs, rollin' through muck and mud." They take refuge in Marshall, Mich., a sanctuary on the Underground Railroad, where they remain until slave chasers track them down. After a confrontation in which the town rallies behind them, the Crosswhites steal away for Canada, accompanied by January, who has shown up unexpectedly. Like Polacco's prose, her dynamic and sometimes brutal pictures, rendered in pencils and markers, hold nothing back--be it the Crosswhites' anguish and terror while under pursuit or their affection for each other and those who harbor them. An illuminating and trenchant account. Ages 8-up. (Oct.) [Page 64]. Copyright 2009 Reed Business Information.
School Library Journal Reviews 2009 September
Gr 4-6--Fleshing out historical events with invented but credible details, Polacco retraces the 1840s flight of the Crosswhite family from slavery to freedom and the dramatic standoff between the residents (black and white both) of the Michigan town where they settled and a band of "paddy rollers" sent to fetch the fugitives back to Kentucky. In lightly idiomatic language ("'Hark now,' their daddy whispered. 'We is gonna cross water tonight!'"), the author relates most of the tale from the point of view of Sadie, the youngest Crosswhite, and threads the narrative with a typical depiction of strong family bonds--expanded here to include the loyalty displayed by a crowd of townfolk who not only held off the paddy rollers until the Crosswhites could escape to Canada, but later paid hefty fines for defying fugitive slave laws. The illustrations, which include scenes of a bloody whipping and a heavily scarred back, have an urgent, unsettled look that fully captures the sharply felt danger and terror of Sadie's experiences. Particularly telling is the contrast between the open, mobile, well-lit faces of the Crosswhites and the shadowed, menacing miens of their pursuers. An iffy claim near the end that Lincoln "gave all slaves their freedom" aside, this moving account effectively highlights a significant instance of nonviolent community resistance to injustice.--John Peters, New York Public Library [Page 171]. Copyright 2008 Reed Business Information.