Reviews for Vanishing of Katharina Linden


Booklist Reviews 2010 June #1
Ten-year-old Pia, who lives in the quaint German village of Bad Münstereifel, is having an especially difficult year in school. Ever since the gruesomely freakish accident that claimed her grandmother's life, she has been unmercifully teased by her classmates. Forced to socialize with the other school outcast, StinkStefan, Pia is only able to forget her troubles when their kindly neighbor, Herr Schiller, invites them over for hot chocolate and beguiles them with ghost stories. When young girls start disappearing from their small town, many parents become hysterical, but Pia and Stefan decide to find out who has taken them. This is the rare debut novel that offers both excellent writing and deft plotting as the young protagonists, unmindful of just how dangerous the world can be, take all kinds of risks to ferret out the kidnapper. For them, it's one big glorious adventure, and their perceptive and often comical takes on the baffling ways of adults add a whole other layer to the central mystery. With a truly terrifying finale, this is a well-crafted, suspenseful blend of literary thriller and coming-of-age story. Copyright 2010 Booklist Reviews.

----------------------
BookPage Reviews 2010 August
Through a child's eyes

Helen Grant’s inventive debut, The Vanishing of Katharina Linden, takes readers into the curious mind of a young girl whose small town is beset by a series of mystifying disappearances. Like Briony in Atonement or Harper Lee’s Scout, Pia Kolvenbach is a precocious observer whose interpretation of events is clouded by her innocence. Susceptible to the fancies of her young imagination, Pia makes a bold choice—to discover the dark truth behind the town’s mystery.

Bad Münstereifel is a classic German village, a quaint blend of medieval and post-war architecture, rife with gossip. When her Oma Kristel dies in a bizarre accident involving too much hairspray and an open flame, Pia becomes notorious at her school as the girl whose grandmother exploded. Ostracized, she is left with only one friend, Stefan, another outcast. So when one of her schoolmates, Katharina Linden, disappears without a trace, Pia is relieved that the town’s attention finally shifts away from her family—albeit remorseful that her social salvation has come through such a horrible occurrence.

Katharina’s vanishing, only the latest in a number of similar incidents through the years, instills a sense of alarm among the parents in Bad Münstereifel, who impose strict curfews on their children. Another girl disappears, then a third, and the townspeople adopt an angry-mob mentality, focusing their rage on Herr Düster, a taciturn old man with a suspicious demeanor. Pia is surprised to learn that Herr Düster is the brother of Herr Schiller, a kindly neighbor who regularly regales her and Stefan with deliciously grisly folktales about strange doings in the woods on the outskirts of town. Inspired by these tales of witches and pagan rituals, Pia and Stefan vow to get to the bottom of the girls’ disappearances, and with callow determination they plunge into solving the mystery. Of course, that proves a dangerous occupation for two ill-equipped, if bright, pre-adolescents.

Pia’s desire to make things right and become the heroine of Bad Münstereifel parallels her sense of helplessness at home. Her mother is English and yearns to return to Britain, especially once she begins to fear for the safety of her children. Pia’s father, born and raised in the town, and intent on staying, cannot understand his wife’s reaction—nor, in his uninspired German way, her ironic wit. The impasse cuts to the heart of their marriage, but young Pia remains unaware until she is presented with the unimaginable certainty that her parents will divorce and she will be displaced to dreaded Middlesex.

Blending elements of ghost story and intrigue with the classic coming-of-age novel, The Vanishing of Katharina Linden is an original and well-observed tale. Though the mystery at the heart of the story is somewhat protracted and its solution less than surprising, Grant compensates for minor narrative imperfections by creating memorable, wholly believable characters—particularly Pia, a worthy addition to the literary gallery of likeable, resourceful children.

Grant, a native of London, moved her family to western Germany’s Bad Münstereifel in 2001, where she found her inspiration for The Vanishing of Katharina Linden after hearing local folk tales. 

Grant’s imagination—coupled with predigious research and skillful writing—make her an author to watch. 

Copyright 2010 BookPage Reviews.

----------------------
Kirkus Reviews 2010 June #2

Grimm and grimmer fairy tale meets terror in a small German town where girls are being abducted again as they were 50 years ago.

English author Grant's loosely plotted debut opens in Teutonic tragi-comic fashion as the narrator's grandmother, wreathed in hairspray and close to a naked flame, explodes at the dinner table. But domestic horror is only one facet of a story that also includes traditional folk tales, a vision of a gossipy, vaguely malevolent local community, children in peril and the ordinary trials of unpopular, ten-year-old Pia. Daughter of a British mother and German father who bicker constantly, Pia is ostracized at school, her only friend a boy named StinkStefan. When first Katharina Linden and then other girls go missing, Pia begins to ask questions, discovering that some girls also disappeared just after the war, including Gertrud, the daughter of her elderly friend Herr Schiller, whose sinister brother Herr Düster is suspected of blame. More girls disappear, Pia's parents decide to separate and Düster falls under suspicion again, leading to Pia and Stefan's decision to break into his house. The implausible denouement is composed of an interminable sequence of scares and spooks.

Atmospheric moments punctuate a story marked by uncertainties of pace and logic which, despite gruesome content, is probably intended for younger readers.

Copyright Kirkus 2010 Kirkus/BPI Communications.All rights reserved.

----------------------
Library Journal Reviews 2010 June #2

After an unfortunate incident during family Advent dinner in 1998, ten-year-old Pia Kolvenbach becomes known in her German hometown of Bad Münstereifel as "The Girl Whose Grandmother Exploded." Pia, whose mother is one of only three British citizens in the area, is already familiar with the peculiarities of this insular town, but the ostracism she now faces leaves her with only two confidantes: StinkStefan, a classmate and fellow outcast, and grouchy, secretive Herr Schiller, a source of town lore. Attention soon shifts from Pia when a local girl, Katharina Linden, becomes neither the first nor the last girl to go missing. Pia and Stefan, inspired (haunted?) by Herr Schiller's gruesome stories, become determined to investigate the disappearances. Pia is an effective and sympathetic narrator as we learn the town's dark secrets. First novelist Grant, herself a former British resident of Bad Münstereifel, already has a second novel, The Glass Demon, scheduled for publication in 2011. VERDICT A meeting of Harriet the Spy and The Lovely Bones with a dash of Grimm thrown in, this is an engaging mystery and a tender story of children caught in some very adult circumstances. YAs may be drawn to the spookier fantasy elements.--Jenn B. Stidham, Houston Community Coll.-Northeast, TX

[Page 61]. Copyright 2010 Reed Business Information.

----------------------
Publishers Weekly Reviews 2010 April #2

It may seem strange to describe Grant's debut as a charming horror novel, but there's a determined amiableness about the narrative that will appeal to readers who wouldn't typically be drawn to such subject matter. It's December 1998, and 10-year-old Pia Kolvenbach and her family are living happily in the quaint German town where her father grew up, until Pia's grandmother accidentally sets herself on fire and burns to death. A rumor erupts that her grandmother exploded, and, overnight, Pia becomes an outcast. Her only friend from then on is the most unpopular boy in her class, nicknamed StinkStefan. The two of them begin visiting an elderly man who entertains them with ghost stories from local folklore that Pia and StinkStefan hope might help them solve the decades-old mystery of a number of local girls who have gone missing. The story's richness isn't as much in the mystery plot as it is in the finely rendered background, where desperate parents strive to protect their children in an uncertain world, though the simplicity of the narration makes the novel feel lighter than probably intended. (Aug.)

[Page 29]. Copyright 2010 Reed Business Information.

----------------------