Reviews for Crooked Kind of Perfect
Booklist Reviews 2007 November #2
Ten-year-old Zoe longs to have a piano, become a prodigy, and play in Carnegie Hall like her hero, Vladimir Horowitz. But Zoe's father doesn't buy a piano. Instead, he gets her a Perfectone D-60 electric organ, complete with lessons and golden oldies songbooks. Disappointed but game, Zoe starts practicing. Her friend Emma dumps her, but soon Wheeler Diggs starts coming home with Zoe after school every day to hang out with her and, increasingly, with her dad, who is terrified of leaving the house. Meanwhile, Zoe practices for the Perform-O-Rama, where young Perfectone players compete before judges. In short chapters varying from a few pages to two words, this first-person narrative is immediately engaging and increasingly involving. Zoe's world is drawn with sometimes painful precision, her emotions are revealed with empathy, and her story unfolds realistically, without the miracles she hopes for, but with small, sometimes surprising changes. The portrayal of Zoe's father is particularly fine. Sometimes funny, sometimes tender, this is a promising debut for the author. Copyright 2007 Booklist Reviews.
Horn Book Guide Reviews 2008 Spring
Ten-year-old Zoe dreams of becoming a famous piano prodigy. Instead of a piano, though, her father brings home a Perfectone D-60 organ. Zoe's witty voice narrates the book's short chapters. Readers will identify with Zoe's insecurities, laugh at her quirky family, and feel her pride in this winning story about family, friendship, self-confidence, and dreams come (realistically) true. Copyright 2008 Horn Book Guide Reviews.
Horn Book Magazine Reviews 2008 #1
Ten-year-old Zoe Elias dreams of becoming a famous piano prodigy. She imagines wearing a ball gown and playing to cheering audiences at Carnegie Hall. But when her agoraphobic father braves the mall to purchase a piano for her, the bright lights and crowds are too overwhelming. Instead of a piano, he comes home with a "wood-grained, vinyl-seated, wheeze-bag" Perfectone D-60 organ. Zoe is "the opposite of excited," but as her weekly lessons progress, she finds she has some talent with the dual keyboard and the rumba rhythm switch. Even Wheeler Diggs, a weird boy from school who befriends Zoe when her best friend ditches her for the popular crowd, thinks her playing is "cool." Zoe's witty voice narrates the short chapters. Readers will identify with Zoe's insecurities, laugh at her quirky family, and feel her pride when she takes part in the Perform-O-Rama organ competition. While the premise is a bit iffy (Zoe's mother is a money-conscious comptroller unlikely to sanction the organ's purchase) and Zoe seems too mature for a ten-year-old, it's easy to overlook such details in this winning story about family, friendship, self-confidence, and dreams come (realistically) true. Copyright 2008 Horn Book Magazine Reviews.
Kirkus Reviews 2007 September #1
All ten-year-old Zoe Elias has ever wanted is a baby grand so that she can become a star who dazzles Carnegie Hall. She doesn't know how to play, but that's a minor stumbling block. What she gets instead is an old, wheezy organ, a gift from her well-meaning, agoraphobic dad. While workaholic mom is hardly ever home, Zoe resigns herself to learning to play the instrument, all the while encouraged by her skittish father and a newfound supportive pal. Wouldn't you know that she turns out to be great at it and goes on to win in competition? There's a lot of knowing, child-friendly humor here, not the least provided by Zoe's hoot of an organ instructor. Readers should enjoy the fast-paced, brief chapters, silliness and tongue-in-cheek first-person narration. The author doesn't pull out all the stops, and the ending is pat, but this is still a satisfying read. (Fiction. 9-12) Copyright Kirkus 2007 Kirkus/BPI Communications. All rights reserved.
Publishers Weekly Reviews 2007 August #3
Former bookseller Urban makes a highly promising fiction debut with this sweet, funny novel, relayed in short, titled entries. Ten-year-old Zoe dreams of becoming a famous pianist (as she says in "How It Was Supposed to Be," "A piano is sophisticated. Glamorous. Worldly"). But her quasi-agoraphobic father has one of his usual freak-outs as he attempts to shop for a piano and buys her an electric organ instead. How can Zoe possibly become the next Vladimir Horowitz if she has to play on a "Perfectone D-60"? Grudgingly, she begins taking lessons from Mabelline Person (pronounced "Per-saaahn "), who hands Zoe songbooks full of TV theme songs or hits from the '70s ("My piano teacher was supposed to be a sweet, rumpled old man," Zoe confides to readers. "I would call him Maestro…. He would discourage me from practicing too much and spoiling the spontaneity of my play"). But when Mabelline enters her in the Perform-O-Rama--her first contest ever--Zoe thinks for the first time that her dreams could possibly come true. Throw in an absurdly workaholic mother, a best friend who deserts Zoe for a girl with a rhyming name (Joella Tinstella), an underparented boy who blossoms overnight when Zoe's dad takes him under his wing, and Zoe's dad's eccentricities, if not to say full-blown neuroses; Urban controls these exaggerated elements through the evenness of Zoe's voice. No matter how outrageously her subjects behave, the author always sounds natural. Ages 8-12. (Sept.) [Page 68]. Copyright 2007 Reed Business Information.
School Library Journal Reviews 2007 September
Gr 4-6-- An impressive and poignant debut novel. Eleven-year-old Zoe dreams of giving piano recitals at Carnegie Hall. When her father purchases a Perfectone D-60, though, she must settle for the sounds of the organ rather than the distinguished sounds of a baby grand. Her organ teacher, Mabelline Person, notices the child's small talent for music and recommends her for the "Perfectone Perform-O-Rama"; she will play Neil Diamond's "Forever in Blue Jeans." Accepting this new twist to her ambitions, Zoe must depend on a quirky support system: her father, who gets anxious when he leaves the house and who earns diplomas from Living Room University; her workaholic mother; and her classmate Wheeler, who follows Zoe home from school daily to spend time with her father, baking. Playing television theme songs from the '60s and '70s rather than Bach doesn't get Zoe down. Instead, aware of the stark difference between her dream and her reality, she forges ahead and, as an underdog, faces the uncertainty of entering the competition. In the end, resilient and resourceful Zoe finds perfection in the most imperfect and unique situations, and she shines. The refreshing writing is full of pearls of wisdom, and readers will relate to this fully developed character. The sensitive story is filled with hope and humor. It has a feel-good quality and a subtle message about how doing one's best and believing in oneself are what really matter.--Jennifer Cogan, Bucks County Free Library, Doylestown, PA [Page 209]. Copyright 2007 Reed Business Information.