Reviews for Selection
Booklist Reviews 2012 May #1
In a dystopian future in which the U.S. is a monarchy, 35 young women are randomly selected to be on a reality-TV competition to win the heart of Prince Maxon, heir to the throne. It's a caste-driven society, where people are ranked from One (royalty) to Eight (untouchables), and poverty, famine, and ignorance are the fate of those ranked Six and below. America Singer, a Five with tremendous musical gifts, ends up as one of the contestants but has no desire to become queen, as she's in love with Aspen, the Five next door. Cass' immensely readable debut novel is a less drastic Hunger Games (2008), with elaborate fashions and trappings. America is torn between Aspen and Maxon, who she discovers really is a nice guy. The book is clearly pitched for romance readers, and the fast-paced action and comforting predictability of the love story will have readers gasping for the upcoming sequel, in which our heroine will continue to grapple with her intense feelings for her two suitors and her growing awareness of the messy political happenings in her country. Copyright 2012 Booklist Reviews.
Horn Book Guide Reviews 2012 Fall
Stubborn, independent, musically talented teen America Singer reluctantly enters the Selection, competing with thirty-four girls to become Prince Maxon's wife. By the dramatic close of this first series installment, both a love triangle and a tense political situation emerge. TV's The Bachelor meets caste-based future dystopia in this original, addictive, and well-written novel.
Kirkus Reviews 2012 March #2
It's a bad sign when you can figure out the elevator pitch for a novel from the get-go. In this case, if it wasn't "The Bachelor meets The Hunger Games," it was pretty darn close. In a rigid, caste-based dystopian future, Illéa's Prince Maxon has come of age and needs to marry. One girl will be chosen by lottery from each province to travel to the Capital and live in the palace so the prince can make his choice. The winning girl will become queen, and her family will all be elevated to Ones. America, a Five, doesn't want to join the Selection because she is in love with Aspen, a Six. But pressure from both her family and Aspen causes her to relent, and the rest is entirely predictable. She's chosen, she goes to the palace, she draws the ire of the other girls with her beauty and the interest of the prince with her spunky independence. Prince Maxon is much nicer than she expected, but she will remain loyal to Aspen. Maybe. Shabby worldbuilding complements the formulaic plot. Scant explanation is made for the ructions that have created the current political reality, and the palace is laughably vulnerable to rebels from both the North and the South, neither of whom are given any credible motives. But there's lots of descriptions of dresses. A probably harmless, entirely forgettable series opener. (Dystopian romance. 13 & up) Copyright Kirkus 2012 Kirkus/BPI Communications.All rights reserved.
Publishers Weekly Reviews 2012 April #2
A cross between The Hunger Games (minus the bloodsport) and The Bachelor (minus the bloodsport), this trilogy launch employs multiple conventions of the dystopian romance genre--strong-willed heroine, heart-wrenching love triangle, far-future setting divided by class. That said, it's a lot of fun. In a post WWIII U.S. divided by caste, teenage America Singer and her family are Fives, struggling musicians and artists. In love with a Six, America is headed for a life of servitude and hunger, until she is chosen for the Selection--a contest through which Prince Maxon will pick his princess. The Selection brings America instant notoriety and prestige, but also thrusts her into a ring of jealous, desperate girls all trying to win the prince's heart. Cass (author of the self-published The Siren) deftly builds the chemistry between America and Maxon, while stoking the embers of America's first, forbidden love. Headstrong and outspoken, America is an easy heroine to root for, and the scenes where she tries to fit in to her new royal life are charming. A TV drama based on the books is in production. Ages 13-up. Agent: Elana Roth, Red Tree Literary. (May) [Page ]. Copyright 2012 PWxyz LLC
School Library Journal Reviews 2012 June
Gr 8 Up--Reminiscent of Shannon Hale's Princess Academy (Bloomsbury, 2005) and Ally Condie's Matched (Dutton, 2010), Cass's debut novel weaves an engrossing tale of high-stakes competition and the emotional turmoil of being true to oneself. In this first installment of a dystopian trilogy, fiery-haired beauty America Singer, 17, meets all the criteria to enter the lottery of a lifetime, a reality-TV-type competition for Prince Maxon's hand in marriage. Her mother believes that she has what it takes to prevail, but America wants nothing to do with the prince. She has secretly been seeing Aspen, whose family members have been servants and friends to the Singers for years. Grappling with her family's socioeconomic status and the impact of the caste system's prejudice on her star-crossed love, America finally concedes to enter the lottery and earns a spot among the lucky 35 contenders, every girl's desire-except for America herself. The sincere prose conveys her minimalist character and reluctance to compete for the affections of a stranger. Fairy-tale lovers will lose themselves in America's alternate reality and wish that the next glamorous sequel were waiting for them.--Jamie-Lee Schombs, Library Journal HC [Page 116]. (c) Copyright 2012. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
VOYA Reviews 2012 February
In a futuristic society that functions through a strict caste system, seventeen-year-old America Singer finds herself in the middle of the Selection, a once-in-a-lifetime lottery designed to take thirty-five girls from all caste levels to compete for Prince Maxon's heart--and crown. America does not want the prince; she wants Aspen, her true and forbidden love. When Aspen suddenly informs her that they have no future, she decides that she owes it to her family and herself to participate in the competition. As the battle for Prince Maxon's affection heats up, America discovers that he might be just what she needs to get over Aspen. This book serves as the first installment of a planned trilogy, which focuses on romance and fairy-tale endings that strongly mirror ABC's reality television show The Bachelor. There is little to no action (other than two random "rebel" attacks that are never really explained and an occasional "mean girl" outburst), which causes most of the scenes to become repetitive and boring. As a result, the plot barely touches on dystopian themes and the character development is superficial and predictable, leaving the reader without quality connection or interest. Therefore, readers who enjoy commonplace romances will gravitate to this novel while dystopian lovers who revel in series such as Suzanne Collins's The Hunger Games (Scholastic 2008/VOYA October 2008) and Uglies (Simon Pulse, 2005/VOYA June 2005) will be disappointed.--Courtney M. Krieger 2Q 4P M J S Copyright 2011 Voya Reviews.