Reviews for Some Pig! : A Charlotte's Web Picture Book


Horn Book Guide Reviews 2007 Spring
The second chapter in [cf2]Charlotte's Web[cf1] is called "Wilbur"; here it's renamed and extracted for full illustration as a picture book. The precise and perfect words remain White's, but without the story arc of preceding and succeeding chapters, the picture book ends abruptly (with Wilbur lying in a pile of manure). The art is prettily rendered, but c'mon, is this book really necessary? Copyright 2007 Horn Book Guide Reviews.

----------------------
Kirkus Reviews 2006 October #2
Kneen contributes a set of serene, soft-toned scenes to the complete, unaltered second chapter of Charlotte's Web, in which Wilbur (who positively radiates with personality in the pictures) gets plenty of TLC from Fern, and is finally sold to the Zuckermans. Expertly riffing on Garth Williams's delicacy of line and subtle modulations of color, the illustrator captures the intensity of feeling that passes between girl and pig, as well as the sunny rural milieu they inhabit. As an extracted episode it hangs together reasonably well, though the ending is abrupt and without much sense of closure. No substitute for the full story, but a worthy stand-in for fledgling readers not yet up to tackling the original on their own. (Picture book. 6-8) Copyright Kirkus 2006 Kirkus/BPI Communications. All rights reserved.

----------------------